In the realm of industrial materials, 904L vs 316L stainless steel is a comparison frequently encountered by engineers, Mga metalurhiko, and procurement specialists.
Both alloys belong to the austenitic stainless steel family, prized for their corrosion resistance, mekanikal na integridad, and adaptability across industries.
Gayunpaman, habang ang 316L is a widely used, cost-effective solution for many general-purpose applications, 904L is a premium-grade stainless steel specifically engineered to perform under highly corrosive and aggressive conditions.
Choosing the correct material between 904L and 316L can significantly affect not only the initial investment but also long-term operational costs, kaligtasan, at pagiging maaasahan,
particularly in sectors such as pagproseso ng kemikal, langis & gas, marine, pagbuo ng kapangyarihan, and pharmaceuticals.
1. What is 316L Stainless Steel?
316L is a low-carbon version of 316 hindi kinakalawang na asero (the “L” stands for “low carbon,” typically ≤ 0.03%).
It is one of the most widely used stainless steels in industrial and commercial environments due to its balance of corrosion resistance, weldability, at abot kayang presyo.
Key Features of 316L:
- Austenitic Structure: Provides excellent ductility, tigas na tigas, and non-magnetic behavior in the annealed condition.
- Paglaban sa kaagnasan: Good resistance to general corrosion, especially in chloride environments like marine or coastal regions.
- Weldability: Napakahusay. Low carbon content minimizes the risk of carbide precipitation during welding, avoiding intergranular corrosion.
Common Standards:
- ASTM A240 / A276
- EN 1.4404
- UNS S31603
2. What is 904L Stainless Steel?
904L ay isang super austenitic stainless steel designed for exceptional corrosion resistance in highly aggressive environments.
It contains significantly higher levels of nikel, molibdenum, at tanso, which enhance its resistance to acids, particularly sulfuric and phosphoric.
Key Features of 904L:
- Super Austenitic Structure: Extremely stable and non-magnetic, even after cold working. Maintains toughness across a wide temperature range.
- Paglaban sa kaagnasan: Napakahusay, especially against sulfuric acid, phosphoric acid, and chlorides. Often used in conditions where standard stainless steels like 316L would fail.
- Weldability: Mabuti na lang, but requires skilled technique. Post-weld init paggamot (solusyon annealing) may be necessary for optimal corrosion resistance.
Common Standards:
- ASTM B625 / A276 / A312
- EN 1.4539
- UNS N08904
3. Chemical Composition of 904L vs 316L Stainless Steel
| Elemento | 316L (%wt) | 904L (%wt) | Function in Stainless Steel |
| Carbon (C) | ≤ 0.03 | ≤ 0.02 | Reduces risk of intergranular corrosion; improves weldability by minimizing carbide precipitation. |
| Chromium (Cr) | 16.0 – 18.0 | 19.0 – 23.0 | Provides corrosion and oxidation resistance by forming a stable passive film on the steel surface. |
| Nikel (Ni) | 10.0 – 14.0 | 23.0 – 28.0 | Stabilizes the austenitic structure; Nagpapabuti ng ductility, tigas na tigas, at paglaban sa pag-crack ng kaagnasan ng stress. |
| Molibdenum (Mo) | 2.0 – 3.0 | 4.0 – 5.0 | Enhances resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion, lalo na sa mga kapaligiran ng klorido. |
| Mga mangganeso (Mn) | ≤ 2.0 | ≤ 2.0 | Gumaganap bilang isang deoxidizer; improves hot-working properties and resistance to scaling. |
| Silicon (Si Si) | ≤ 1.0 | ≤ 1.0 | Improves oxidation resistance; also used as a deoxidizer in the melting process. |
| Posporus (P) | ≤ 0.045 | ≤ 0.045 | Kept low to avoid embrittlement and maintain ductility. |
| Sulfur (S) | ≤ 0.03 | ≤ 0.035 | Improves machinability in small amounts; excess can reduce toughness and corrosion resistance. |
| Tanso (Cu) | ≤ 0.5 | 1.0 – 2.0 | Increases resistance to reducing acids, especially sulfuric acid; enhances corrosion resistance in harsh chemical environments. |
| Nitrogen (N) | ≤ 0.10 | ≤ 0.10 | Strengthens the austenitic structure and improves pitting resistance and tensile strength. |
| Bakal na Bakal (Fe) | Balanse | Balanse | Base metal of stainless steel, contributes to strength and magnetic properties. |
4. Corrosion Resistance Performance
Pangkalahatang kaagnasan
- 316L stainless steel offers reliable corrosion resistance in neutral or mildly corrosive environments like seawater or food processing.
- 904L stainless steel demonstrates superior durability in aggressive environments such as sulfuric acid or chloride exposure, up to six times better performance in acid resistance tests.
Pitting at Crevice Corrosion
- Pitting Resistance Katumbas na Numero (PREN):
-
- stainless steel 316L: ≈24–27
- stainless steel 904L: ≈36–39
- Higher PREN in 904L makes it far more resistant to localized corrosion, making it preferable for offshore, marine, and chloride-heavy process use.
Stress kaagnasan pagbasag (SCC)
- SCC susceptibility is markedly reduced in super-austenitic steels.
- 904L stainless steel’s high nickel content enhances resistance to CCS, making it better suited for chemically aggressive environments.
5. Mechanical and Physical Properties of 904L vs 316L Stainless Steel
| Pag-aari | 316L Hindi kinakalawang na asero | 904L Hindi kinakalawang na asero | Remarks |
| Lakas ng Paghatak (MPa) | 485 – 620 | 490 – 740 | 904L has higher upper-end strength, beneficial for structural applications. |
| Yield Lakas (0.2% Offset, MPa) | ≥ 170 – 310 | ≥ 220 – 290 | 904L has slightly better yield strength, with good ductility retained. |
| Pagpapahaba (% sa 50 mm) | ≥ 40 | ≥ 35 | 316L is slightly more ductile; better for cold forming. |
| Ang katigasan ng ulo (Brinell HBW) | ≤ 217 | ≤ 220 | Similar hardness levels; both are suitable for machining and fabrication. |
| Densidad ng katawan (g/cm³) | 7.99 | 8.05 | 904L is slightly denser due to higher alloying content. |
| Modulus ng Pagkalastiko (GPa) | ~193 | ~195 | Nearly identical; determines stiffness under load. |
| Thermal kondaktibiti (W/m·K) | 16.3 | 12.5 | 316L has better thermal conductivity; important in heat exchangers. |
| Tiyak na Kapasidad ng Init (J/kg· K) | 500 | 450 | 316L retains heat slightly better. |
| Koepisyent ng Thermal Expansion (μm/m·°C) | 16.0 × 10⁻⁶ | 15.0 × 10⁻⁶ | 904L has lower thermal expansion; better dimensional stability at high temps. |
| Electrical Resistivity (µΩ·cm) | ~74 | ~94 | 904L has higher resistivity; relevant for electrical and EMI-sensitive uses. |
| Magnetic Permeability (μr) | ~1.02 (non-magnetic in annealed condition) | Hindi magnetic (μr ≈ 1.0) | 904L is fully non-magnetic; beneficial in sensitive equipment. |
6. Fabrication and Weldability of 904L vs 316L Stainless Steel
Fabrication processes such as welding, machining, pagbuo ng, and heat treatment significantly affect the final performance and cost of stainless steel components.
Weldability
| Aspeto | 316L Hindi kinakalawang na asero | 904L Hindi kinakalawang na asero |
| Welding Method Compatibility | Suitable for all standard welding methods (GTAW, GMAW, SMAW) | Suitable but requires more care; recommended for TIG and MIG processes |
| Tagapuno ng Metal | Commonly uses 316L or 308L electrodes | Requires matching 904L filler or high-alloy austenitic filler (hal., ER385) |
| Preheat/Post-weld Treatment | Not typically required; low carbon prevents carbide precipitation | Post-weld solution annealing may be needed to restore corrosion resistance |
| Hot Cracking Susceptibility | Mababa ang | Higher due to high alloy content; controlled heat input is critical |
| Sonang Apektado ng Init (HAZ) | Minimal degradation | Greater risk of corrosion if not properly post-treated |
Pangunahing Pananaw:
316L offers mahusay na weldability with minimal post-weld treatment.
904L, although weldable, mga kahilingan higher skill, special filler metals, and often post weld heat treatment to maintain corrosion performance in aggressive environments.
Machinability
| Pag-aari | 316L | 904L |
| Machining Difficulty | Katamtaman; better than most high-nickel alloys | Mahirap; Mabilis na pag-aayos ng trabaho |
| Tool Wear | Normal with carbide tools | Mataas na; requires coated tools and coolant |
| Kalidad ng Pagtatapos ng Ibabaw | Good finish achievable | Can be rough; slower speeds required |
| Recommendations | Use sharp tooling and moderate speeds | Use rigid tooling, mas mabagal na bilis, higher feed rates |
Pangunahing Pananaw:
904L’s higher nickel and molybdenum content increases its trabaho hardening rate, making it harder to machine than 316L.
Specialized tooling and machining strategies are required to avoid tool wear and poor surface finish.
Formability and Cold Working
| Forming Behavior | 316L | 904L |
| Malamig na Pagbuo | Mahusay na ductility at formability | Mabuti na lang, but more springback and force required |
| Annealing Needs | Sometimes needed after heavy cold work | Often required due to higher work hardening |
| Bending and Rolling | Performs well without cracking | May need wider radii or multi-pass forming |
Pangunahing Pananaw:
While both are suitable for forming, 316L is easier to bend, deep draw, or roll-form. 904L is stiffer and may require Intermediate Pagsusubo during complex forming operations.
Casting and Heat Treatment
- Paghahagis:
316L is more commonly used in precision pamumuhunan paghahagis due to its stable structure and cost-effectiveness.
904L can be cast, but its higher alloy content can lead to segregasyon at hot tearing, Nangangailangan more controlled cooling at refined casting techniques. - Paggamot ng Heat:
-
- 316L: Non-hardenable by heat treatment; solusyon annealing (~1050–1100°C) used to restore corrosion resistance.
- 904L: Also non-hardenable, pero post-weld annealing (1100-1150 ° C) is often recommended to regain full corrosion resistance, particularly after severe cold work or welding.
7. Applications of 904L vs 316L Stainless Steel
Applications of 316L Stainless Steel
316L (Mababang Carbon 316) ay isang versatile, corrosion-resistant alloy widely used in industries where moderate chemical exposure and good weldability are required.
Its lower carbon content minimizes carbide precipitation during welding, making it especially suitable for fabrication-intensive applications.
| Industriya ng Industriya | Mga Karaniwang Aplikasyon |
| Pagproseso ng Kemikal | Storage tanks, process vessels, pipelines for acids and caustics at moderate concentrations |
| Parmasyutiko | Cleanroom and sanitary equipment, bio-reactors, tablet presses |
| Pagkain & Email Address * | Dairy processing, brewing tanks, Email Address *, at mga balbula |
| Marine | Seawater piping (short exposure), boat fittings, and decks in mildly corrosive environments |
| Mga Medikal na Kagamitan | Orthopedic implants, kirurhiko instrumento, diagnostic kagamitan |
| Arkitektura | Facades, Mga handrail, fasteners exposed to mildly corrosive atmospheres |
| Langis & Gas | Downhole screens, Email Address * (non-sour service), and separators in offshore platforms |
Applications of 904L Stainless Steel
904L is a super austenitic stainless steel designed for use in extremely aggressive environments, especially those containing Mga klorido, Sulpuriko acid, or reducing agents.
Its higher contents of nickel (23–25%), molibdenum (4–5%), and copper give it exceptional resistance to pitting, kaagnasan ng bitak, at pag-crack ng kaagnasan ng stress.
| Industriya ng Industriya | Mga Karaniwang Aplikasyon |
| Kemikal & Petrochemical | Acid handling equipment (sulpuriko, Phosphoric), mga reaktor, mga heat exchanger, at mga vessels ng presyon |
| Mga Halaman ng Desalination | Brine tanks, Mga Evaporator, and high-chloride pipeline components |
| Marine & Malayo sa pampang | Deep-sea pipelines, Mga Riser, mga bomba, and valve housings exposed to long-term seawater |
| Battery & Mga Elektronika | Components exposed to sulfuric acid in lead-acid battery production |
| Pagmimina & Metalurhiya | Slurry pumps, autoclaves, and leaching systems (especially for nickel and copper ores) |
| Pulp & Paper | Bleaching plant equipment exposed to aggressive chemicals |
| High-End Consumer Goods | Luxury watches (hal., Rolex uses 904L for its exceptional luster and resistance) |
| Pollution Control | Flue gas desulfurization (FGD) units in power plants |
8. Buod: Choosing Between 904L vs 316L Stainless Steel
Selecting the right stainless steel grade between 904L at 316L requires careful evaluation of the application environment, mga kinakailangan sa pagganap, fabrication considerations, and cost factors.
Comprehensive Comparison Table
| Aspeto | 316L Hindi kinakalawang na asero | 904L Hindi kinakalawang na asero |
| Paglaban sa kaagnasan | Good resistance to mild corrosives and chlorides; moderate pitting resistance | Superior resistance to aggressive chlorides, Sulpuriko acid, at mga oxidizing agent; excellent pitting resistance |
| Komposisyon ng kemikal | Ni ~10–14%, Mo ~2%, minimal Cu | Ni ~23–25%, Mo ~4–5%, Cu ~1.5–2% |
| Mga Katangian ng Mekanikal | Magandang tigas, ductility, at lakas | Higher strength and hardness; slightly less ductile |
| Gawa-gawa & Welding | Napakahusay na weldability; minimal heat treatment | More difficult welding; often requires solution annealing |
| Gastos | Lower raw material and fabrication cost | Higher raw material cost due to alloying elements; higher fabrication cost |
| Mga Aplikasyon | Food processing, mga parmasyutiko, moderate chemical exposure, paggamot ng tubig | Harsh chemical processing, marine, sa malayo sa pampang, acidic and chloride-rich environments |
| Service Life & Pagpapanatili | Moderate service life with regular maintenance | Extended service life with reduced maintenance |
| Mga Katangian ng Magnetic | Slightly magnetic after cold working | Essentially non-magnetic |
When to Use 316L Stainless Steel
- Applications where mahusay na paglaban sa kaagnasan is needed in moderately aggressive environments
- Cost-sensitive projects where nickel and molybdenum contents are balanced for performance and price
- General-purpose marine, pagproseso ng pagkain, at kagamitang medikal
- Situations requiring easy fabrication and welding
When 904L Stainless Steel is Essential
- Exposure to highly aggressive chemicals such as sulfuric and phosphoric acids
- Environments with high chloride concentrations where enhanced pitting and crevice corrosion resistance is critical
- Industrial equipment requiring long service life under severe corrosion conditions
- Kapag maximum corrosion resistance justifies the higher material cost
11. Pangwakas na Salita
316L vs 904L stainless steel are proven austenitic stainless steels with distinct characteristics.
SS 316L is reliable and cost-effective for most applications, habang ang SS 904L offers enhanced corrosion resistance, lakas ng loob, and reliability in more demanding environments.
Engineers and specifiers should weigh material costs against service conditions to determine the best choice.
Madalas na, the higher upfront investment in 904L is offset by reduced maintenance and longer service life, particularly in aggressive settings.
LangHe: Precision Stainless Steel Casting & Fabrication Services
LangHe is a trusted provider of high-quality stainless steel casting and precision metal fabrication services, serving industries where performance, tibay ng katawan, and corrosion resistance are critical.
With advanced production capabilities and a commitment to engineering excellence, LangHe delivers reliable, customized stainless steel solutions to meet the most demanding application requirements.
Our Stainless Steel Capabilities Include:
- Pamumuhunan sa Paghahagis & Nawala ang Wax Casting
High-precision casting for complex geometries, ensuring tight tolerances and superior surface finishes. - buhangin paghahagis & Paghuhulma ng Shell
Ideal for larger components and cost-effective production, especially for industrial and structural parts. - CNC Machining & Pagkatapos ng Pagproseso
Complete machining services including turning, paggiling, pagbabarena, buli na, and surface treatments.
Whether you need high-precision components, complex stainless assemblies, or custom-engineered parts, LangHe is your dependable partner in stainless steel manufacturing.
Makipag ugnay sa amin ngayon to learn how LangHe can deliver stainless steel solutions with the performance, pagiging maaasahan, and precision your industry demands.
Mga FAQ
Is 904L better than 316L stainless steel in all applications?
Not necessarily. While 904L offers superior corrosion resistance—especially in highly aggressive environments—it is also more expensive and harder to fabricate.
For general industrial, grado ng pagkain, and pharmaceutical uses where corrosion conditions are mild, 316L is often sufficient and more cost-effective.
What makes 904L stainless steel more corrosion-resistant than 316L stainless steel?
Stainless steel 904L has higher contents of nikel (23–25%), molibdenum (4–5%), at tanso (1.5–2%), all of which enhance resistance to acidic na kapaligiran, Chlor-induced pitting, at kaagnasan ng bitak.
Ang ganda nito super austenitic structure provides excellent stability in harsh media such as sulfuric acid and seawater.
Can 316L and 904L stainless steel be welded together?
Oo nga, but careful attention must be given to filler material selection and heat input. Karaniwan, a nickel-based filler (such as ERNiCrMo-3) is used to bridge the metallurgical differences.
Post-weld heat treatment may also be necessary, especially on the 904L side, to restore corrosion resistance.
Why is 904L stainless steel commonly used in the marine and offshore industries?
Ang ganda nito excellent resistance to chloride-induced corrosion, lalo na pitting and crevice corrosion, makes it ideal for saltwater exposure, splash zones, and subsea applications.
Unlike 316L, 904L maintains integrity in stagnant or warm saltwater environments over long service periods.
Is 904L stainless steel magnetic?
Hindi, 904L stainless steel is essentially di-magnetiko in all conditions, including after cold working.
This makes it suitable for applications that require low magnetic permeability, such as in certain electronic, instrumentation, at kagamitang medikal.
How much more expensive is 904L compared to 316L stainless steel?
The cost of stainless steel 904L can be 2–4 times higher than that of 316L, depending on market pricing of nikel, molibdenum, at tanso.
Additional costs may also arise from specialized fabrication, hinang, and post-treatment processes.
Can 904L be used in sulfuric acid environments?
Oo nga. 904L is one of the few stainless steels that provides excellent resistance to dilute sulfuric acid—even outperforming some nickel alloys in specific concentrations.
It’s widely used in fertilizer plants, acid storage tanks, at Mga reaktor ng kemikal.
